You are not logged in. Click here to sign up or login here.
 
log in | sign up | rss feed
 
         
 
   
 
Recent Columns - Bakari Chavanu
Canon 50D From Snapshots to Great Shots - Book Review
Wednesday, 05/13/09

Four Photoshop CS4 Books Reviewed
Tuesday, 05/05/09

Two equally great books about Adobe Lightroom 2 - Review
Monday, 01/19/09

From Canon XSi to Photoshop CS3 Accelerated - Three Book Reviews
Monday, 11/24/08

The Moment It Clicks - Review
Tuesday, 07/22/08


Recent Blogs - Bakari Chavanu
Connecting iPhone to iTunes
Thursday, 08/14/08

AppleScript: Email Opens a Webpage
Wednesday, 04/30/08

Jazzy Smart Playlists
Saturday, 03/15/08

5 More Mail Rules
Saturday, 01/26/08

The Canon Powershot G9
Tuesday, 01/22/08


Archive - Bakari Chavanu
2003


   
Ten Missing Features in iMovie '08
Bakari Chavanu
Writer
Thursday, 08/09/07


In this my second post about iMovie '08, I thought I'd make a quick list of important features that are missing from this latest version of iMovie. I'm pretty sure that Apple will either have to do something about upgrading iMovie '08 really soon or continue to maintain and support iMovie HD, the previous iMovie version.

So here are 10 major iMovie HD features that I can't find in iMovie '08.

1. No audio extraction feature. As I said in my first post about iMovie '08, the lack of an audio extraction feature is a serious development flaw. Extracting audio from video clips are very useful for advance editing. Sure, you can silence audio in video clips and bring in say music or sound effects in the background, but you can't extract audio from video clips that you captured while shooting. Until this feature is included in iMovie '08, I will definitely not be using it for advance work.

2. No chapter markers for DVD authoring. Seriously don't know why that isn't here, especially since that has been a major integration between iMovie and iDVD for at least the last two versions of both programs.

3. No iMovie themes. iMovie HD comes with really nice cinematic themes that you can use at the beginning through your movie. They're completely gone from the latest version.

4. Lack of control over fade-in and out of audio. iMovie '08 does the fading out for you. That's okay for simple projects, but not good for advance editing.

5. You cannot open completed projects in older versions of iMovie in the newer '08 version. You can import the source clips of older projects, but you'll lose the transitions, special effects, and maybe even music tracks you imported into the older projects.

6. You can't slow down or speed up the content of a clip! I can't find this feature anywhere in iMovie '08. Another serious development flaw.

7. No advance video editing controls. Apple included Audio FX and Video FX in iMovie HD, but only parts of these features appear in iMovie '08. You can do some color adjustment of clips and normalize the audio of clips. But that's it. Gone are FX features like Pitch Changer, LowPass, Fast/Slow/Reverse, or Aged Film adjustments.

8. No support for third-party plug-ins. I'm not a developer, but I would bet that third-party plug-ins for iMovie '08 will have to be built from scratch. It doesn't appear as if existing iMovie HD plug-ins can simply be upgraded with a few code changes for iMovie '08.

9. There's no pause control for titles. You can change the speed duration, but you can't set for how long you want a title to show after it's fad in. You'll have to make a still clip if you want the title to pause and then fade out.

10. While iMovie '08's library feature enables you access all your iMovie projects, it doesn't appear that you can have more than one project open at a time. You have to switch back and forth between projects that are listed in the library pane.

I'm sure there are a few more features present iMovie HD that are not found in iMovie '08. The lack of the above features is a serious disappointment for avid and even professional users of iMovie.

The smartest thing that Apple did with introducing iMovie '08 is not cause it to replace iMovie HD. There's little doubt that avid and professional users of iMovie will continue to use iMovie HD until major and much need improvements are made to '08.


Article Discussion
MyMac welcomes reader feedback to our Article Discussion area below. Please REGISTER to become a free contributor, or LOGIN.


Great articles, Bakari. Keep them coming! Thanks.

[Nemo]


Posted by John Nemerovski


Great stuff....
Posted by Rich Lefko


Thanks for the useful articles.

Posted by sjk


I was angry when I read your list -- no audio extraction? What the--??!!

But then I discovered that you're wrong.

To extract audio, select the clip, and hold down Apple+Shift as you drag it onto your timeline. Only the audio goes, and then you can move it around at will.
Posted by blahblah


Most of these are spot on, Bakari. Hopefully they will find their way back. I thought you'd like to know that you *can* extract audio, but the feature has been buried in the help documentation. (I still haven't actually found it there. An Apple support rep helped me with this feature.) I started a little iMovie '08 blog posting tutorials as I learn how to do things. Here is a walkthrough on extracting audio.

http://imovie08.blogspot.com/2007/08/how-to-extract-audio-from-clip.html

Also, chapter markers can be done in GarageBand. It's not elegant, but it's not too much hassle.

http://imovie08.blogspot.com/2007/08/how-to-add-chapter-markers.html

I hope these are useful to you. Here's hoping that the other features you listed will be added in future updates.

-Aaron
Posted by ilifer08


And what happened to the time line?

silvia
Posted by silvia33



MyMac welcomes reader feedback to our Article Discussion area below. Please REGISTER to become a free contributor, or LOGIN.
 
ipod speakers




















Links:
Keylogger Mac

Laptop

Interested in
getting your
links here?
Email us.


Last Updated
February 8, 2010 14:00 CST
 



InnoTech
Proud host of MyMac.com for over 12 years

| Home | Archives | eBooks | Reviews | Video | PodCasts | PR |

  Copyright ©1995-2010 MyMac Productions and Tim Robertson. All Rights Reserved.
Owner/Publisher: Tim Robertson       Webmaster: Tim Robertson