|
|
|
Navigate: | My Mac Online | The Archives | December 1997 | Book Bytes | |
![]() |
|
THE GREAT COMMUNICATOR BROWSER BOOK WARS: EIGHT AND COUNTING!
By John Nemerovski
| Discover Netscape Communicator | Netscape Navigator 4 and Communicator Bible | The Complete Idiot's Guide to Netscape Communicator 4 | Using Netscape Communicator 4 | Netscape Communicator 4 (6-in-1) | Special Edition Using Netscape Communicator 4 | Teach Yourself Netscape Communicator 4 in 24 Hours | The Big Guide to Netscape Communicator 4 | Just when you thought the Web browser wars were leveling off, here come eight new titles on the topic of Netscape Communicator 4, with multiple offerings from each publisher. You should see my desk. It's groaning under the weight of all these books competing for my attention. Oh, no! The wooden desk legs are buckling from the burden.Departing from my normal chatty format, I will attempt to identify the features of each book which make it worth considering (or rejecting) in comparison to its competitors. Fair enough? Here goes.
UNIQUE FEATURES: A sturdy tear-out Discovery Central card, with excellent visual shortcuts. The 42-page Discovery Center, following the final chapter, on pale blue paper. It provides systematic chapter-by-chapter tasks and techniques for every action and command within the suite of applications. Appropriate page numbers are indicated. In addition, a nine-page Visual Index displays every basic Navigator screen, with captions, lines, and arrows leading the the corresponding on-screen button or window. GRAPHICS AND SCREENSHOTS: Plentiful and appropriate, at nearly one per page. SPECIAL ICONS, FORMATTING, AND SIDEBARS: Used in moderation. WRITING STYLE: Lively and informative. OVERALL LOOK AND FEEL: I like it. VALUE FOR MONEY: Very good.
UNIQUE FEATURE: A lengthy explanation of "The Extras in the Professional Edition" of Communicator. GRAPHICS AND SCREENSHOTS: Plentiful and appropriate. SPECIAL ICONS, FORMATTING, AND SIDEBARS: Outstanding. WRITING STYLE: Extremely thorough, and easy to read. OVERALL LOOK AND FEEL: A valuable learning and reference work. VALUE FOR MONEY: Overpriced, unless you need the Win95 disk.
UNIQUE FEATURES: The Knowledge Base dedicated Web site for technical support assistance. Judd Winick cartoons at the beginning of every section. GRAPHICS AND SCREENSHOTS: Plentiful and appropriate. SPECIAL ICONS, FORMATTING, AND SIDEBARS: Abundant, and very helpful. WRITING STYLE: Breezy and conversational. OVERALL LOOK AND FEEL: Cute, and smart. VALUE FOR MONEY: Good.
GRAPHICS AND SCREENSHOTS: Plentiful and appropriate. SPECIAL ICONS, FORMATTING, AND SIDEBARS: Adequate. WRITING STYLE: Lively and informative. OVERALL LOOK AND FEEL: This is a useful book. VALUE FOR MONEY: Good.
Netscape Communicator 4 (6-in-1) UNIQUE FEATURE: A HTML Reference Section listing supported tags and attributes. GRAPHICS AND SCREENSHOTS: Plentiful and appropriate. SPECIAL ICONS, FORMATTING, AND SIDEBARS: Abundant, and comprehensive. WRITING STYLE: Very straightforward, making excellent use of numbered, structured lessons covering every imaginable aspect of Communicator. OVERALL LOOK AND FEEL: This is a practical and helpful book. VALUE FOR MONEY: Good.
UNIQUE FEATURES: Very instructional and thorough series of chapters on creating Web pages. In general, an exhaustive and patient approach to the entire suite of applications. GRAPHICS AND SCREENSHOTS: Plentiful and appropriate. SPECIAL ICONS, FORMATTING, AND SIDEBARS: Abundant, and comprehensive. WRITING STYLE: Lucid and direct. OVERALL LOOK AND FEEL: This heavyweight tome aims to provide full-service, and it delivers the goods. As with many of the books, the examples here are primarily taken from Windows screen shots, but most of the information is viable cross-platform. VALUE FOR MONEY: Good.
UNIQUE FEATURE: Step-by-step "hourly" 24-lesson format, complete with quizzes. GRAPHICS AND SCREENSHOTS: Plentiful and appropriate, often with several on a page. SPECIAL ICONS, FORMATTING, AND SIDEBARS: Abundant. WRITING STYLE: This book is written from a friendly, helpful first person point-of-view. OVERALL LOOK AND FEEL: Comfortable, informative, and approachable. VALUE FOR MONEY: Very good.
UNIQUE FEATURES: Over 170 yellow pages of "Web Hot Spots" from the Infoseek search engine. Extensive Web page creation chapters. Specific "Tips, Tricks, and Timesavers" on each component of Communicator. GRAPHICS AND SCREENSHOTS: Plentiful and appropriate, often with several on a page. SPECIAL ICONS, FORMATTING, AND SIDEBARS: Abundant. WRITING STYLE: Personal, easygoing, and informative. OVERALL LOOK AND FEEL: This is a learning and reference book which is both impressive and effective. VALUE FOR MONEY: Excellent.
Whew! So there we have it. The choice is yours, and whichever book you purchase, read it and use it! Let me know how you agree or disagree with my evaluations, or if you find a superior book.
John Nemerovski (nemo@mymac.com)
Websites mentioned:
Book Bytes - Previous Columns
|
|
Copyright ©1995-2000 My Mac Productions, All Rights Reserved |