TurboTax 2003 Deluxe for Mac – Review

On March 29, 2004, in Uncategorized, by John Nemerovski


TurboTax 2003 Deluxe for Mac
Company: Intuit
Price: $50 (discounts are often available)
http://www.intuit.com

It’s that time of year again, friends. TurboTax Deluxe 2003 for Mac contains changes and improvements that will affect both how you enter your financial data and how you look ahead to potential tax savings for 2004 and beyond. Newcomers to TurboTax initially will be perplexed and annoyed at the powerful application’s way of proceeding through its Easy Step data entry process. They’ll agree with me that upon completion the labyrinthian journey was worthwhile.

I have reviewed and commented extensively on Intuit’s TurboTax and MacInTax. All my earlier postings are available via our MyMac.com archives. Annual familiarity with this software gives me an advantage during the data entry process, but leads me to skip over or blast through sections that might hinder you.

Competition is limited, yet intense, for your tax filing assistance fees. Intuit intends to be a one-stop shop, with individual and business applications that potentially could serve most U. S. citizens. If my tax filing ordeal wasn’t such a personal black hole for a lovely Sunday in March, I would try several different methods offered by this company and others, including all-online filing.

Here are the modest requirements for using TurboTax Deluxe 2003 on your Macintosh:

Memory—32MB RAM required
CPU—PowerPC Processor
HD Storage—Requires approximately 95 MB hard disk space
Connection—28.8 kbps required for online features, product updates and electronic filing
Printer—Most Mac-compatible inkjet or any Mac-compatible laser printer with at least 1 MB of memory
Operating System—Mac OS 8.6- Mac OS 9.x; Mac OS X (10.1 or greater)
Monitor—640×480 screen resolution, 800×600 recommended
CD-ROM Speed—2X CD-ROM required, 4X recommended
Browser—QuickTime 6 or greater is required to view videos

I took extensive notes during the three hours I devoted to installing, examining, and using this year’s TurboTax. Everything went smoothly, which is a relief. Product updates consume a nominal quantity of time over a broadband Internet connection, but may require hours via a phone line. I glanced through Gene Steinberg’s terrific new title, Mac OS X 10.3 Panther Little Black Book from Paraglyph Press whenever downloads or update installers took more than a few seconds.

We reviewers have access to an online press kit, but you’re not missing much that won’t become obvious during the taxing process. I have a few minor gripes about TurboTax 2003, some of which carry over from previous years’ reviews:

• UNDO (Command+Z) doesn’t work to clear or remove data from individual entry boxes or cells. Why not?

• NAVIGATORS (Page Up, Page Down, etc.) are not active within Easy Step screens, requiring users to navigate only with a mouse. Why the limitation?

• MANUAL or QuickStart Guide is nonexistent. I understand that TurboTax is loaded with built-in help features, but how are beginners supposed to know what to do out of the package?

Here is some praise:

SAVINGS are convenient, with free shipping and handling for orders before April 15, plus handy rebates for many purchasers.

QUICKTIME embedded tutorials are presented with clarity and quality.

CHANGES in tax law were substantial last year, but they are handled transparently by TurboTax.

LANGUAGE within the application is easy to follow.

LINKS for every imaginable sort of help are abundant.

A few tips from Nemo:

ARCHIVE your tax report onto an external hard drive, CD, and personal email account every time you wrap up a session.

COLLECT every possible paper and digital document in advance of beginning the TurboTax ordeal.

TURN OFF your phone and stereo, so your brain and fingers will focus on the hours-long task.

STRETCH every 30 minutes, and remember to drink some water and have a healthy snack each hour.

PENCIL a check mark in the corner of each piece of paper you complete, then cross-check it for accuracy on a different day.

OBTAIN your bank tracking number ahead of time, because you’ll need it for electronic refund transmittal.

This 2003 edition of TurboTax for Mac feels a bit more tedious than the previous couple of years, even though my financial situation (ugh) is mostly similar. I can’t quantify the experience, but I expect Intuit spent plenty of time achieving their goal of personalizing the reporting and filing experience for a potential tens of millions of taxpayers.

If I were not a product reviewer, would I still buy and use TurboTax? Yes, definitely. I understand its way of relating to me and my finances, and I’m generally comfortable with its procedures. With comprehensive tutorials, help links, Easy Step and Forms features, I’m giving TurboTax Deluxe 2003 for Mac our MyMac.com rating of 4 out of 5.

If you have questions, comments, or gripes concerning TurboTax that are not addressed within the application, post your situation below in our Article Discussion area. Other readers (or possibly Intuit personnel) may be able to dig you out of a hole, if you’re not in a crisis.

 

BT500 Bluetooth Mouse – Review

On March 29, 2004, in Uncategorized, by Jason Rainbows

BT500 Bluetooth Mouse
Company: BlueTake Technology

Price: $89.00 (US)
http://www.bluetake.com

BlueTake Technology’s new BT500 Bluetooth Mouse is a zippy little portable 2-button optical mouse with scroll wheel. A perfect companion for those of us who use a laptop and need more precise cursor control than a trackpad allows – with cordless convenience!

The Bluetooth USB Receiver included with the mouse is about the size of a typical USB Flash Drive and is a multi-purpose receiver – it should work with most Bluetooth products including cell phones and Bluetooth enabled PDAs. Since some companies (starts with an M and has a dollar $ign in the middle) include proprietary receivers that only work with their mice, it’s nice to have just one receiver that will work with all your Bluetooth devices (the BT500 is also available (MSRP $59.00 US) without Bluetooth USB receiver).

The mouse itself is tiny; less than 3 inches long and about one and a half inch wide, but masterfully designed. The battery compartment is sturdy and the ergonomics are about as perfect as you can get at this sportingly small size. The weight is 64 grams without the batteries; with the batteries, it has enough heft and stability to take moderate abuse, but feels like a fine precision instrument.

Included in the package is a 7-page manual for the mouse itself, plus a 78-page manual covering software installation, configuring, etc., etc, etc.

Yep, I said "a 78 page manual". But don’t let this intimidate you! For I, dear reader… I eat manuals like this for breakfast. Stand back and leave it to me to digest these 85 pages into a simple 3-step instruction.

Let’s see… Hmmm, this all pertains to the Windows operating system. Nothing here at all about configuring this thing on a Mac. Also included are 2 mini-CDs full of (ugh) Windows software. Okay. This is to be expected. Translating this to the language of Macintosh shouldn’t be too hard – here goes…

Step 1. Firmly place the 78-page manual along with the two Mini-CDs in the trash.

Step 2. Open System Preferences panel and click Bluetooth. Click the "pare device" buttons.

Step 3. There is no step 3.

I left out a few details, like inserting the batteries and hitting the ON switch, but you get the idea – OS X handles Bluetooth like a champ.

Which brings me to another nice feature of this mouse – the ON/OFF switch.

You will find that many Bluetooth mice don’t have an ON/OFF switch, since they automatically go to sleep after a few minutes. But if your mouse is jostled around inside your knapsack or laptop bag, it’s going to be turning on and off constantly wasting precious battery-life. The ON/OFF switch is neatly located beneath the BT500 mouse, where it is out of the way and recessed enough to avoid accidental switching.

Battery life is decent, but not remarkable. With the included AAA batteries, I got about seven days’ use. But I put this baby through some VERY HEAVY usage. No mercy. We’re talking 16-hour days here folks. No coffee breaks! Bathroom only in emergencies! Keep a spare pair of rechargeable batteries with you. When the batteries go low, the mouse just stops working, necessitating a battery change on the fly. Thankfully, the battery compartment snaps open in a flash and if you have a couple of replacements on hand, a battery change takes only a few seconds.

Of course, the first thing I did with this mouse was to test it out in the various versions of Unreal Tournament. It worked perfectly without having to configure anything except the Mouse Sensitivity. Its 800 dpi optical sensor is a lot zippier than any of my other mice. Slowing down Mouse Sensitivity a bit increased my precision markedly. After several hours of DeathMatch with my friend Bill, and winning more than half the maps played (he’s pretty good), I decided that this was going to be my favorite mouse for fragging.

The BT500 also performed very admirably in several highly detailed PhotoShop projects. I was impressed with its accuracy and dependability. The small mouse glides effortlessly across any surface with precise cursor tracking and, despite its diminutive size, produced no finger fatigue with prolonged use.

My contract with MyMac.com clearly states that I can only use my superhuman eyesight for the "betterment of mankind", so I took the mouse clear across the room, and controlled the Macintosh from way back by the birdcage. Yeah, I know! I was impressed too! That’s like 20 feet away! I eat a lot of carrots.

The B500 is an excellent product for everyday use. If it had a recharging dock, I would have very little reason not to give it my highest recommendation. It’s not the perfect mouse for everybody; it’s really very small and you have to live with the fact that the batteries will expire while you’re working. But if you have a need for a miniscule mouse without the tether of a cord, the B500 is a real performance machine.

MyMac Rating: 4 out of 5

 

Weekend Archive – How do you win an award?

On March 27, 2004, in Uncategorized, by MyMac Administrator

This weekend, we look way back to May 1997 and one of our illustrious alumni, Shay Fulton. “How do you win an award?” looks at some of the events and products from 1996 – 1997, and is a great way to take a peek at the Mac landscape seven years ago! Read it here!

 

Rock Star – Review

On March 23, 2004, in Uncategorized, by Tim Robertson

Rock Star
Company: Freshly Squeezed Software

Price: $9.00 (US)
http://freshlysqueezedsoftware.com

I have a love for music that goes beyond the average person. At least, I believe that is true. And I enjoy all kinds of different types of music, leaving off Opera and most Country Music. My eclectic tastes are reflected with a quick trip to my iTunes music library, where you will find, as of last count, 5,236 songs. And that is after weeding out a ton of songs I know I will probably never listen to.

While browsing the net the other day, I came across the Freshly Squeezed Software site, and found the program Rock Star. The caption reads “It’s you against the music” on the main page, and that was enough to intrigue me.

Rock Star is a single or multi-person music game that uses your very own iTunes library in a very new and innovative way. Do you remember the old game show “Name That Tune”? Neither do I, way before my time. But the concept is similar here. Rock Star will play clips of your own iTunes music library, and give you five multiple-choice answers.

The game gives you the choice of game play. You can either guess song title, artist, album, or a mixed bag of all three. During game play, you are presented with five choices, and the goal is to correctly answer in the shortest amount of time as possible. During game play, there is a counter the quickly counts down, so that when you make a correct selection, you are awarded the time left of the counter.

Multi-player games, or “Party Games” as they are called, are a great deal of fun as well. Here, you can have up to five teams, and you rotate teams every five songs. The highest scoring team wins. As the title suggests, this is a fun party game.

It sounded simple enough. Really, if it is using your very own music library, music you listen to all the time, it should be simple as can be. Trust me when I say, though, that it is anything but. I know my music, and I am stumped often.

Rock Star is a very addictive and fun game, and the cost is not only affordable, but well worth the investment in a small software publishing company that is making some great strides in creativity and functionality. Hats off to Freshly Squeezed Software!


MyMac.com Rating: 5 out of 5

 

LaCie Porsche Design External Hard Drives — Review

John Nemerovski & David Weeks

F. A. Porsche Design External FireWire and USB Hard Drives
Company: LaCie Limited

Prices: From $129 (see reviews for details)
http://www.lacie.com

LaCie continues to support our favorite computers with a strong presence in Apple Stores, at Macworld Expos, and in the Macintosh print media. Recent advertising campaigns feature attractive young people in “lifestyle poses” (LaCie’s wording, not ours) promoting their stylish Porsche Design family of external drives.

Competitors were not impressed during informal conversations at January’s Macworld Conference and Expo. One well-known retailer’s CEO said: “I’ll gladly go head to head against LaCie’s Porsche products any day of the week.” He wasn’t convinced that these affordable, lightweight drives are worthy of the highly-regarded LaCie name. Neither was David Weeks, our lead reviewer.

David’s comments come first, with insights and tech specs on both Porsche / LaCie drives.


Before running the hardware benchmarks on the two La Cie drives, I took a few minutes to examine the drives themselves. La Cie styles each model in this line quite similarly. Let’s look at each drive in turn.

LaCie USB Mobile 80 GB Hard Drive
Company: LaCie Limited
Price: $319 US
http://www.lacie.com

First comes an 80 gigabyte Pocket Drive. The 2.5" mechanism is encased in an attractive gun-metal grey housing, with connectors at the back end of the case. This pocket drive has USB 2 or 1.1 only, so it’s of limited appeal to the great majority of Macintosh users whose high speed connectors are exclusively FireWire. OS X now supports USB 2, but you’ll still need a PCI card to provide the hardware capability if your Macintosh doesn’t work with the faster version. An installer disk loads LaCie’s OS 9 software, which is not necessary for OS X computers.

A quick glance at Froogle (a splendid Google offshoot for pricing information) shows that PowerBook users can find USB 2 PC cards for $55 and up. Desktop Mac owners can obtain internal USB 2 cards for $20. I found mine at CompUSA, and it played perfectly out of the box.

While not as fast as FireWire, USB 2 performs adequately, as the benchmarks show.

Results 28.34

System Info
Xbench Version 1.1.3
System Version 10.3.2 (7D24)
Physical RAM 1024 MB
Model PowerMac3,6
Processor PowerPC G4x2 @ 1.42 GHz
Version 7455 (Apollo) v3.3

  • L1 Cache 32K (instruction), 32K (data)
    L2 Cache 256K @ 1.42 GHz
    L3 Cache 2048K @ 237 MHz
    Bus Frequency 167 MHz
    Video Card ATY,RV250
    Drive Type TOSHIBA MK8025GAS
  • Disk Test 28.34
    Sequential 19.61
    Uncached Write 34.37 14.33 MB/sec [4K blocks]
    Uncached Write 33.57 13.75 MB/sec [256K blocks]
    Uncached Read 8.22 1.30 MB/sec [4K blocks]
    Uncached Read 42.67 17.24 MB/sec [256K blocks]
    Random 51.08
    Uncached Write 46.77 0.70 MB/sec [4K blocks]
    Uncached Write 58.01 13.08 MB/sec [256K blocks]
    Uncached Read 48.75 0.32 MB/sec [4K blocks]
    Uncached Read 52.16 10.73 MB/sec [256K blocks]

    While XBench was testing the drive, I took a few minutes to examine the unit more closely. La Cie provides a small power/activity light on the front of the case, but it’s recessed so far in that you can’t see it unless you are looking directly at it; the light’s invisible if you look at it from off to the side.

    The high-impact plastic case is rather insubstantial and lacking in solidity. I could easily flex the case with light finger pressure. I didn’t get any confidence that this case could stand up to rigors of daily transportation in a laptop bag.

    All told, I see no reason why at Mac user would buy a flimsy USB 2 drive, especially a PowerBook user looking for portable storage.

    David’s MyMac.com rating 2 out of 5


    John Nemo says:

    While I agree with David’s observations, I praise LaCie for making this USB porta-drive exclusively bus-powered. All previous USB disks we’ve seen have required an electrical current to function. Given its ease of use, high-capacity, low price, and portability, I’m comfortable with:

    John’s MyMac.com rating 3 out of 5

    Whoa! During our second round testing the portable Porsche, we learned that David’s heavy duty G4 + USB 2 card powers the drive, but his brand new USB 2-native 15" PowerBook doesn’t. How strange. We’ll contact LaCie to learn if the problem is with their drive or his laptop, and provide an addendum as soon as possible. ANSWER: It’s an Apple bug, which David confirmed after extensive research: specific to PowerBooks and bus-powered USB devices. Be aware!



    LaCie FireWire 80 GB Hard Drive
    Company: LaCie
    Price: $129 US

    http://www.lacie.com

    David says:

    Next comes LaCie’s 80 gigabyte FireWire desktop drive. While this unit uses two Mac-friendly FireWire 400 connections, it also suffers from lightweight construction, and the poorly-placed activity light. This drive performs better than the its little sibling, but don’t waste a stamp writing home about great performance, because the drive has merely average specs.

    Results 78.24

    System Info
    Xbench Version 1.1.3
    System Version 10.3.2 (7D24)
    Physical RAM 1024 MB
    Model PowerMac3,6
    Processor PowerPC G4x2 @ 1.42 GHz
    Version 7455 (Apollo) v3.3
    L1 Cache 32K (instruction), 32K (data)
    L2 Cache 256K @ 1.42 GHz
    L3 Cache 2048K @ 237 MHz
    Bus Frequency 167 MHz
    Video Card ATY,RV250
    Drive Type WDC WD80 0BB-00CAA1

    Disk Test 78.24

    Sequential 72.25
    Uncached Write 83.07 34.63 MB/sec [4K blocks]
    Uncached Write 80.93 33.14 MB/sec [256K blocks]
    Uncached Read 57.54 9.11 MB/sec [4K blocks]
    Uncached Read 73.59 29.73 MB/sec [256K blocks]
    Random 85.31
    Uncached Write 80.83 1.21 MB/sec [4K blocks]
    Uncached Write 90.30 20.37 MB/sec [256K blocks]
    Uncached Read 81.69 0.54 MB/sec [4K blocks]
    Uncached Read 89.28 18.37 MB/sec [256K blocks]

    Most users would be advised to spend a few more dollars for a drive with sturdier construction, and the newer, faster FireWire 800 ports.

    La Cie stamps "Designed by F.A. Porsche" on this line of drives. F.A.Porsche is the creative house that designs the bodies on Porsche sports cars. If I were F.A. Porsche, I’d be reluctant to have my name on a series of drives with middle of the road performance.

    David’s MyMac.com rating 2.5 out of 5


    John adds:

    We may be splitting hairs here, David, but millions of current Mac owners will be glad to be able to purchase an inexpensive external FireWire 400 drive such as this one. Its limitations and assets balance one another, leading to:

    John’s MyMac.com rating of 3 out of 5

    _________


    John Nemerovski


    David Weeks

     

    Weekend Archive – Everyone Loves A Mac

    On March 20, 2004, in Uncategorized, by MyMac Administrator

    Is it true that Everyone Loves A Mac? Chris Seibold said so two years ago in this article!

    "Hey, Windows Guy, You want a Mac, You Just don’t Know it (and the real reason most people use Windows)" Read the article here!

     

    NoteRiser – Review

    On March 17, 2004, in Uncategorized, by Owen Rubin

    NoteRiser
    Company: Conotour Design

    Price: $129
    http://www.contourdesign.com

    When I first received this device, I had to ask myself “Why do I need this?” The idea seemed a bit strange to me. You buy a laptop computer, and then you use this device to basically turn it into a fancy desktop computer, which means I have to add an additional external keyboard and mouse? I did not get it, if I wanted a desktop computer, I would have bought one. And then I bought and started using my 17” PowerBook, and the benefits of such a device started to become more obvious.

    For one thing, today’s laptop computers run very hot. My PowerBook’s internal temperature can reach easily over 125 degreed Fahrenheit during normal operation. And when this happens, the keyboard and palm rests also become very hot, almost too hot to continue working. Sitting flat on the desk, the machine tends to get very little air circulation around the unit, so I thought getting it off a flat surface might help. In addition, while I bought this PowerBook to use while I travel, I do find myself using it at a desk a lot more often than while traveling. And if you are like me and this IS your main machine, then this device makes even more sense for you. I spend a good deal of time sitting at a desk and working on my laptop, placing me in one of the worst ergonomic positions one can sit to work. So I decided to try the NoteRiser out.

    The unit comes packed very flat, and can be flattened again for carrying in a suitcase or briefcase to use in multiple locations. At 11.8” wide, 10.63”deep, and only .16” thick, and at less than 1 pound, it will not be a burden to carry either. To use, you simply lift and lock two front tabs which act as forward, PADDED computer rests (the front edge of the computer sits against them), and then raise the angle of the base by moving the “adjustment tongue” to set the tilt angle between 20 and 55 degrees.

    That’s it! Simply place your laptop on top against the pads, plug in your keyboard and mouse, adjust and your screen now sits at a more comfortable and correct viewing angle, distance, and height. The NoteRiser not only places your screen at the correct location, but also allows you to place the external keyboard at a more correct ergonomic position as well, so overall you reduce neck, back, shoulder, arm, wrist and eye strain while using your computer at a desk. That alone is a good thing.

    And for me, the computer dropped about 5 degrees sitting raised up like this so that air could circulate about it. The NoteRiser is made of an ultra thin and lightweight metal that should also bleed off some of the excess heat too. And once I got use to using an external keyboard, I found the higher screen position to be much more easy on the eyes.

    This device can also be “integrated ”to the laptop. While these additional parts were not included with my trial unit, these additional strips allow you to attach the NoteRiser in a quasi-permanent way to the bottom of the laptop. I was not able to test this method, but would probably not do this on my machine anyway as the battery access door is on the bottom and this type of install would make access to the battery impossible.

    While this unit does work with my 17” PowerBook, it was not ideal. First off, one of the little front rest pad sits inconveniently in front of the slot loading DVD drive, making the drive useless without lifting up the computer each time. Secondly, the 17” has a very cool back-lit keyboard which is no longer used in this configuration…what a waste. And while I did not feel as if it would fall, the extra weight and width of this large PowerBook computer did make the unit seem a bit unstable sitting on the stand. A 12” and 15” PowerBook should have no stability problem, but drive access to front loading drives will be a problem.

    While the NoteRiser has 5 soft pads on the bottom as to not damage the desk surface (especially when installed permanently, when raised, the back “foot”, which raises the computer has no such soft padding on it. This means a rounded, but still sharp, metallic edge is now holding up the entire weight of your computer on your desk surface. In my case, this DID scratch the wood surface of my table. Given the padding everywhere else on this device, this was a stupid oversight that just damaged my desk. Lastly, using the laptop while sitting on this device is not easy or recommended, and an external keyboard and mouse is a must.

    My only other issue is with the price, which I felt was a bit steep for such a simple, small device. While this is a great concept, and putting a price on a proper ergonomic set-up is difficult, I felt the $130 price, given that I must also buy an external mouse and keyboard, was about twice what it should cost, but you will have to be the judge of that.

    More information can be found at http://www.contourdesign.com

    MyMac rating: 2.5 out of 5

     

    Learning Unix for Macintosh OS X Panther
    Author(s): Dave Taylor and Brian Jepson

    Publisher: O’Reillly and Associates
    ISBN: 0596006179 Pages: 155

    Reviewer: Tony Williams

    Since the advent of OS X Mac users have had to get used to the idea that under their favourite GUI lurks a real operating system. While for some (such as myself) this has been a source of joy for others it has been like Central Africa for Victorian England — the great dark heart.

    Dave Taylor and Brian Jepson have provided a good map for those just starting to explore, "Learning Unix for Mac OS X Panther".

    They start at the obvious place, starting Apple’s ‘Terminal’, before talking a about customizing the shell. The second chapter delves deeper into the Terminal and explains the syntax and types of CLI commands. Chapters 3 and 4 clarify the Macintosh and Unix file systems. The book then goes on to explain printing, redirection, pipes and multitasking before a chapter on ‘net stuff, one on X11 and Fink before a quick look at further avenues of exploration.

    The book is fairly well written, assuming almost nothing at the beginning and easily read, though a little less haste in the writing and editing would have been good – there are some tiny patches of clumsy or inaccurate writing. This is certainly a beginner’s book. If you have had any Unix experience and are not afraid of a little exploration on your own then this book is almost entirely superfluous. That said, if you want hand holding and a push in the right direction then this is a good book for Macintosh users.

    It does have its flaws. The simplistic approach is a little too simplistic at times. For example, in the discussion of redirection they explain standard in and standard out but totally neglect standard error which may leave users wondering why a redirected program still has some terminal output and not knowing how to capture all output to a log file, for example. It also moves a little too slowly, I often find beginner books are pitched at people who want a lot of hand holding, I think you can safely assume any Macintosh user who wants to learn about the Unix underpinnings will be prepared to do a little work and thinking along the way. Due to these problems I find myself still looking for the modern, Macintosh equivalent of Kernighan and Pike’s "Unix Programming Environment", a book I recommended as the best intro to Unix for many years.

    To have a look at the usual O’Reilly page here’s a link. This one has the table of contents, index and an example chapter. The chapter is the one on printing, not a perfect example but it will show you the writing style. It also contains an example of the slight sloppiness, there is a table that lists possible options for enscript including -W to specify an output language and correctly mentions the possibilities as PostScript, overstrike, HTML and RTF but fails to mention that enscript is quite fussy about the case you use to specify the language so you have to use ‘-W html’ or ‘-W rtf’, oh, and it has to be ‘-W PostScript’ not ‘postscript’

    This is not the sort of book that you will need forever; a quick read and a slow read in front of the computer will have most people understanding everything that Taylor and Jepson explain in this book. The small size and price may justify the shortcomings if you think of this as a book that you buy and pass along. I find myself still able to recommend it for people who want a book right at the beginning of the learning curve.

    Rating: 7/10 – Good book with some flaws

    Tony contributes book reviews to MyMac.com. You can read more at Tonys Book Spot – Reviews and News

     

    Google in bed with Porn sites?

    On March 15, 2004, in Uncategorized, by Tim Robertson

    Google in bed with Porn sites?

    I was watching a TV magazine program, and one of the features was on the growing popularity of homemade pornography. I was not really interested in the segment, but I did leave it on as there was a segment coming up later that I did want to see. Usually when I am watching a program in the kitchen, as I was on this night, I will read a book during the commercial breaks, or in this case, during a segment of a program I don’t much care about.

    Then I heard the reported on the program mention home video editing, and I glanced up. There was a home video editing computer, and guess what it was? If you said a G4 Macintosh, you’re right. (This was before the G5 came out.) And it struck me as off that this home porn producer was using an Apple Macintosh, and from what you could see on screen, iMovie as well.

    I made a note to do some further research on this sometime in the future, thinking perhaps it would make an interesting article. I never really got around to writing it, though. So that note sat in my FileMaker database of potential story ideas for over a year.

    I came across my note the other day, and decided to do some preliminary work on the article. I was curious to find out if any other site had done a like story. The only one I knew about was an old Rodney Lain article at, I think, MacObserver. Could have been AppleLinks. (I am simply too lazy right now to go check.)

    So I did a search on Google for “Macintosh Porn” hoping to come up with some hits. Of course, most results were porn sites, as I expected, but those are easily avoided simply by looking at the URL and the brief description. (On a side note, I did find this article from CNN.com that I found interesting.)

    Google returned 131,00 results. Way too many for me to look through. But what else I found was rather surprising.

    Google makes a ton of money with their “AdWords” feature, which is the small text advertising displayed on the right hand side of the page at Google after you perform a search. These are targeted ads, based on your search criteria. They are easily ignored, which I usually do. But this is what I found after doing the above search.

    Forgive me for blurring out the URL, but I don’t really want to promote a porn address here

    Needless to say, I was quite surprised. Google takes ads from pornography web sites? Since when? Google will soon be a publicly traded company.

    I am no prude. I don’t have a problem with adult entertainment websites. I don’t frequent them, but if you do, that is your business. I could care less. I also don’t want to see government regulating them. But I digress.

    Here is what bothers me.

    I was seriously thinking about using the Google AdSense. What this program does is display Google’s AdWords ads on your site, and you get paid when a visitor to your site clicks on of these ads. Sounded good to me, and these are targeted ads, meaning that Mac resellers or the like would have their ads displayed at MyMac.com.

    So I signed up for an account, before I really decided whether or not to use the service or not. No harm in signing up, no obligations, and if I decided to do it, I would already be halfway done with any needed work.

    The next day, I received this email from Google:



    Hello Tim,

    Thank you for your interest in Google AdSense. After reviewing your application, our program specialists have found that the website currently associated with your account does not comply with our policies. Therefore, we’re unable to accept you into Google AdSense at this time.

    We did not approve your application for the reasons listed below. If you are able to resolve these issues, please feel free to reply to this email for reconsideration when you have made the changes.

    Issues:

    - Inappropriate language

    ———————

    Further detail:

    Inappropriate language: We’ve found that your website contains content that isn’t in compliance with our program policies. We don’t allow websites with excessive profanity or potentially offensive content to participate in Google AdSense. Please review our policies (https://www.google.com/adsense/policies) for a complete list of site content not allowed on web pages.

    ———————

    For a complete list of AdSense criteria, please visit:

    https://www.google.com/adsense/policies

    https://www.google.com/adsense/terms

    If you would like to submit another website for consideration, simply reply to this email and provide us with the URL. If this new website complies with our program policies, we will help you start delivering AdWords ads in minutes.

    Please contact us at adsense-support@google.com if you have any questions.

    Regards,

    The Google Team


    Needless to say, I was surprised and a little angry. So I sent off this reply:



    Thank you. Can you specify which words were appropriate? There is one article with the F word used, but that was totally appropriate and in fact was recognized by an anti-suicide organization. Otherwise, we are a family oriented website.

    Tim




    I waited only a few hours before I received this reply:

    Hello Tim,

    Thank you for your continued interest in Google AdSense.

    Our AdSense representatives review all AdSense applications according to our Terms and Conditions ( http://www.google.com/adsense/terms ) and our program policies ( http://www.google.com/adsense/policies ). I apologize if the prior disapproval of your application was made in error.

    I have now reviewed and confirmed that your website , www.mymac.com , meets all of our policies. Your application has been approved. Please check for a separate application approval email for your records. The approval email also includes detailed instructions on how to access your new account and get started.

    Please feel free to email us at adsense-support@google.com if you have additional questions or concerns. For technical support, please email
    adsense-tech@google.com.

    Sincerely,

    The Google Team


    Well, how do you like that, I thought. They checked us out, and found we were not in violation of their policies after all.

    About those policies…

    How is it that, on one hand, they originally state we violate some inappropriate language policy (Which they later rightly reversed) and on the other, display pornographic ads on their own site? How can these two standards exist at the same time? I clicked that ad to make sure it is what I thought it was. No confusion, let me tell you! The page that loaded was very, shall we say, graphic. Just POW! There it all is, in all its porn glory.

    In fairness, Google does address this issue in their overview page for AdSense: “Across the Google network, ads do not run on publisher sites until they have been reviewed and approved by Google’s editorial team. We classify each AdWords ad as Family-Safe, Non-Family-Safe or Adult/Explicit. Of these, only Family-Safe ads are shown on publishers’ site”

    Sounds nice. What happens when a Webmaster forgets to renew his domain name and his site is hijacked by a porn site? Don’t think it can happen? Do a Google search for “hijacked websites” and find out for yourself.

    Perhaps it is just me, and there is nothing untoward going on here. Google has a right to earn money, and there sure are a lot of Porn websites out there. So is it just me, or is there some flaw here? Use the Article Discussion below and tell me what you think.

     

    After nine years of publishing, it would be hard for this publisher to pick his favorite article. There has been so many, and so many great ones, that to pick just one would be impossible. I could pick the top five, though, and The Gorilla Benchmark Test would defiantly make that list, easy.

    Written in March 1997 (SEVEN years ago!) by Pete Miner, it starts “All this sniveling about who manufactures the better computer has finally driven me to prove, once and for all, who builds the most reliable, innovative and user friendliest computer on the market today. To accomplish this, I conducted my own scientifically controlled Benchmark tests on several of the leading personal computers being sold today

    And the insanity and hilarity ensue… Read it here!

     

    Macs at Work Interview
    Russ Walkowich
    Contributing Editor
    Tim Robertson
    Publisher

    A funny thing happened on the way to the MyMac.com Garage Band Loops Contest. Tim Robertson, owner and publisher of MyMac.com, was monitoring the contest when he noticed that quite a few of the entries for the Garage Band Loops contest were coming from the same email address, and that this Kathy Lies was submitting quite a few entries. Upon closer examination, he noticed that she would put that this entry was from this person and the next email, from another person.

    His interest aroused, he wondered what was going on with these different entries for different people but under one email address. Ms. Lies signature file also mentioned the Wayne Country Day School in Goldsboro, NC. Contacting Ms. Lies to make sure that everything was within the guidelines of the contest, Tim discovered that Ms. Kathy Lies is a teacher and that she had made our Garage Band Loops contest a class project!

    Both Tim and I had the pleasure of interviewing Kathy Lies to get the story behind the Wayne Country Day School – My Mac Garage Band Loops contest class project. So sit back, relax and enjoy as we find out how Macs are being used in the school and a different way of involving students in class projects using a web-based contest came into being.


    MyMac.com: Kathy, welcome to My Mac! Could you describe the class (es) that participated in the contest? What specific class was it?

    Kathy Lies: Actually, I allowed all three of my classes to participate in the contest. They kept opening the GarageBand program instead of what we were working on, and it seemed easier to switch projects and postpone what we were working on!

    MyMac.com: How did you find out about My Mac’s GarageBand Loops contest?

    Kathy Lies: A very good friend came across it and emailed it to me!

    MyMac.com: You must be a fun teacher to let your students create music in class. What do you see as the benefit in this exercise?

    Kathy Lies: I have found that my students generally learn best when they are trying out things for themselves. If I try and “lecture” to them, they tune out- I simply told them about the contest and let them go- they learned everything on their own. Some students became much more adept at finding all the extras, and they taught the others. If they learn things on their own, they will continue to do so, long after they have graduated.

    MyMac.com: How long have you been teaching computer science at the school?

    Kathy Lies: This is my 7th year. I began by volunteering with the Accelerated Reader program around 10 years ago, and was hired to teach part time. I taught kindergarten many many years ago, then went to law school, practiced part time while my children were very small, then as I began volunteering while they were in elementary school, I found I missed
    teaching.

    MyMac.com: GarageBand is an easy program to learn. How much of a learning curve was there for the students to learn?

    Kathy Lies: Practically none- they were off and running immediately!

    MyMac.com: Any future plans for GarageBand in the classroom?

    Kathy Lies: I’m not sure. I could see letting them arrange some of the loops to use as background for a lot of things. They each got to burn a CD of their work to take with them. I did buy myself one of the Keystation 49e keyboards, and I may bring it in later and let them work with it. I also bought the new Finale for myself, and may let them try it with my keyboard.

    MyMac.com: Obviously winning the contest was not the focus for you or the class, but rather teaching was. True?

    Kathy Lies: : True, although I told them if they did win, and didn’t need the hard drive, we could certainly use the donation to the school! ;-)

    MyMac.com: The class looks to be teeming with Apple Macintosh computers, from eMacs to G4 to iMacs. I take it your school district has not gone over to the Windows camp, as have many others. Any reason why?

    Kathy Lies: First of all, we are not a district- just a small private school. It is pre-K through 12th grade. There is a technology committee working to get new funding for the school right now- there are old PC’s scattered about, and this year I leased 17 new eMacs to place throughout the school. Each lower school class has one, and several upper school classes.

    I have had a least one convert from the Dark Side! I use Macs in my lab because I prefer them. They are easier, better for graphics, Multimedia- hey, you know all this! – and easier to maintain. I am the only computer person in the school, and I only work part-time.

    MyMac.com: Are you encountering any resistance to the use of Macs at the school?

    Kathy Lies: Of course. There are a few who have never used Macs and haven’t seen the light- and then there are several who are willing to learn- they have seen the eMacs in the lab. And of course, we have gotten at least one convert!

    MyMac.com: Besides GarageBand, what other applications do the students learn to use?

    Kathy Lies: We use Office, which I teach in Computer Lit I, and AppleWorks (easier to use for databases), Photoshop, Dreamweaver, iPhoto, iMovie, iDVD, iTunes, and even iChat- I can send them messages while they are working without anyone else hearing me! and of course, Internet.

    MyMac.com: What has been the most popular project done this year?

    Kathy Lies: GarageBand, no doubt! Usually the most popular one is with iMovie. They LOVE bringing in pictures, scanning them and making presentations and movies with them. They also use the digital cameras and camcorder.

    MyMac.com: Do the students have Internet access in class? Does the Internet play an important role in day-to-day classroom work?

    Kathy Lies: Absolutely- a parent helped me wire the main building last fall, so we are wireless in the main building. We need new wiring desperately, and everything more up to date, but it was amazing what a difference it made in the use of the computers. A lot of the students bring in laptops, and some are wireless. For those who are not, I have a table in the lab with a couple of Ethernet cables. Sometimes classes will come in to do research on the Internet; some will do the research on the computer in their room.

    MyMac.com: What type of Mac do you use yourself?

    Kathy Lies: I am working on a titanium PowerBook G4. We have an old blue and white G3 desktop which serves as a print center. My older daughter, who is in grad school, has a 12″ iBook, her fiancée has my old G3 bronze keyboard PowerBook, my younger daughter, a sophomore in college, has a 14″ iBook. My husband has an old original PowerBook that he still has to use for Quicken, thanks to their reluctance to update Quicken for Panther. He is sitting with his 15″ iBook now, probably playing Snood.

    MyMac.com: You are deeply involved with the use of Apple computers in your job as a teacher. What would you like to see Apple or a third party vendor produce for use in classroom or just for home use by a Mac user?

    Kathy Lies: I would like to see more programs updated for Panther. My husband’s data files from his old Quicken will not transfer-the information just disappears. Some programs I used to use for school, like HyperStudio, for example, have not been updated for Panther, either. That was a really good program, and was good for showing similarity to making links, like websites. I am still waiting for the PowerBook G5, although it is just as well that it hasn’t come out yet- I still have a little over a year left on my Applecare!

    GarageBand is a really awesome program, but wouldn’t it be great if they could make an inexpensive program that would write the notes in as you play them (on a keyboard)? Finale is really expensive. Also, syncing the iPod and iTunes is a bit confusing for some people- one of my students got an iPod and put on 26GB of music! Then he got a virus (unfortunately, he has an old PC, I think) and had to reformat his hard drive. He didn’t realize that the iPod would erase itself in order to sync with the computer, and he lost it all.

    MyMac.com: How long have you been a Mac user? What first got you started down the path of using Apple gear?

    Kathy Lies: Ever since we got an Apple IIe! My husband brought it home when the children were very small. I was literally afraid to touch it, so he worked the programs for the children. We eventually got a IIGS, and I began using it some. I remember MacWrite, and MacDraw, and one of our favorites, The Learning Center. My children wrote many stories using that program!

    Then we bought an LC and I had to learn about the hard drive- and OS 6. I crashed it (by experimenting with it) so many times that I got tired of calling friends or support and started really paying attention to everything they did. Pretty soon I had figured out how to fix a lot of things. We then upgraded to a PowerMac LC, then we got another, although I don’t recall immediately which one it was, and then the G3 desktop. Then we began the laptop route. I got my husband one of the PowerBooks with a 40MB hard drive and 4 MB memory, and I had an original PowerBook. I dropped it, the display cracked, and I had to get a different one- which turned out to be a lemon- most unusual.

    Apple was great- though it took a long time, my letter writing finally reached someone in Cupertino, and they not only gave me a new laptop, but an upgraded version- the bronze keyboard! I bought the titanium G4 about a year and a half ago. I am a Mac fan for life, and have converted several friends!

    MyMac.com: Kathy, thank you for taking the time to talk with us. Thank you all for participating in My Mac’s Garage Band Loops Contest. We wish you, your students and the school continued success in all your endeavors.

    Mr. Bill Gates proposes “Stamps” for email.

    Mr. Gates believes that since we pay to mail our regular mail, we should pay to email messages. This would serve as a deterrent to spammers because this would be cost prohibitive for them. Does he really believe that dribble? Of course all legal, normal folks would wind up paying.. and as par for the course, the spammers would/will find a way to circumvent the process. So just the normal everyday computer user gets shafted. (Yes, I know that we’re not even talking a penny an email, it’s the principle of the whole idea!!)

    He’s not in control of enough things, computer-wise/software-wise, now he’s proposing that email users “pay” for the privilege of sending email.

    Let me take a really wild guess who would wind up selling these “stamps”… Maybe a profile of Mr. G looking to his left or right… a wreath of olive leaves about his head as befitting an emperor?

    Any other ideas?

    Tagged with:  

    Apple Confidential 2.0- The Definitive History of the World’s Most Colorful Company
    by Owen W. Linzmayer
    No Starch Press
    ISBN 1-59327-010-0
    $19.95 U.S., $29.95 CN
    323 pages

    Back in 2000, I had the pleasure of reading and reviewing Mr. Linzmayer’s first Apple Confidential book, and thought that he had done an outstanding job of presenting the visible and the behind-the-scenes story of Apple Computer. Mr. Linzmayer, a freelance writer and author, had taken his time to delve into the depths of the company that we all love to hate and produced a great book that worked to explain the mysteries of Apple.

    Fast forward to 2004 and he has done it again. Taking the original book, Mr. Linzmayer has updated the story to the present day, continuing the journey from where he left off with Mac OS 8.6 and the original iMac to the present day Mac OS 10.3 and the G5, the iPod and iLife.

    Apple Confidential 2.0, from start to finish, is a continual source of information on Apple Computer and the people involved, from the beginnings in a bedroom (you have to read the book to find out) to the present day activities of Steve Jobs as head of Apple and Pixar. It delves into how the original Apple was taken to numerous companies, like Hewlett-Packard, Atari and Commodore Business Machines in an attempt to sell the Apple computer concept. It covers all the twists and turns that Apple has experienced along the way. Apple Confidential 2.0 provides the reader with information on how Apple came to be, who thought of what, who never got the credit that they justly deserved, or who took the blame when things went wrong. The book includes time lines for Apple from the start of both Wozniak and Jobs in college to the computers, operating systems, peripherals and software from the very start to the present day.

    If you want an easy to read book on the story of Apple and the people involved, get yourself Apple Confidential 2.0. The book is packed with everything you need to know, provides the background on people, and places and things, and it does so without being boring or preachy. A very good read, you’ll find yourself totally engrossed. If you didn’t buy Mr. Linzmayer’s first book, take the time to get the second. Apple Confidential 2.0 will make a great addition to your home library – a must-have for Apple lovers.

    Highly Recommended.

    My Mac Rating: 5 out of 5

    Looking for something?

    Use the form below to search the site:

    Still not finding what you're looking for? Drop a comment on a post or contact us so we can take care of it!